home | books | articles | gleanings | case studies | hire
other sites: widgetopia | blueprints for the web | metafooder


 


 


« From: Gleanings To: Cleanings Subject: | main | what kind of IA are you? »

battle of the titans

or rather, Jef Raskin refuting an Alan Cooper interview:


Here's a taste--


Cooper: "We believe that good design is self-evident."


Raskin: "If you believe that, then you are stuck in a rut, because the value of deep improvements are rarely self-evident, and even when a better design -- if unfamiliar -- is shown to developers or experienced users, they tend to reject it. "


check it out

Posted at April 09, 2001 07:35 PM


Comments

 

I just want to add a clarification here. When Alan wrote that he believes good design to be self-evident, he was speaking in the context of designers. Good designers know when they or others have created a good design. Developers and experienced users, most often, do not (at least not at first impression).

Posted by Elan Freydenson at April 13, 2001 09:11 AM


~~~



Post a comment
*Name:


*Email Address:


URL:


Remember me?

Comments:

bold italic underline link


posting can be slow; please wait a few seconds before hitting the button again.

The extra-fine print
wording stolen by the more-eloquent-than-I kottke
The bold, italics, and link buttons (and associated shortcut keys) only work in IE 5+ on the PC.
Hearty discussion and unpopular viewpoints are welcome, but please keep comments on-topic and *civil*. Flaming, trolling, and ass-kissing comments are discouraged and may be deleted.
All comments, suggestions, bug reports, etc. related to the comments system should be directed to me.


mail entry to a friend

Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):




« From: Gleanings To: Cleanings Subject: | main | what kind of IA are you? »

 

 

 

home | books | articles | gleanings | case studies | hire
other sites: widgetopia | blueprints for the web | metafooder